[Abstract] He Zhengping appeal without killing intent, after investigation, wrote a suicide note before He Zhengping crime planned revenge, buying tools of the crime as murder, waiting waiting waiting to commit crime, knife-stab stab victim in a row after small hole in head and neck, chest and more than more than 10 knife, in people continues to still hold when they intercepted the small hole poked thorns, kill people intentionally obvious.
(Legal evening news reporter Hong Xue Wu Jie Wu Jie edit) because transfers do not have to declare in advance, resulting in hospitalization costs 300 yuan less reimbursement, farmers He Zhengping, yiyang city, Hunan province, believes that because Yue Jia Qiao town, heshan district of yiyang city hospital did not give him a referral to prove, should bear the loss. Find each other repeatedly request was refused, He Zhengping desire revenge. Hole in the hospital financial officers of a 10 year old son hole on his way to school He Zhengping knife pierced holes 13 knife holders and children were seriously injured.
Deep reading of, the legal evening news said today that on February 16, 2017, Hunan province High Court make a final judgment on the case.
High Court in Hunan province believe that He Zhengping whims of medical expenses, are determined to kill after hospital staff, squat down with a knife after failed, hospital staff regardless of the dispute’s youngest son commit murder, aggravated crimes and crimes with cruel means, subjective evil, social harm is serious, should be sentenced according to law. Given He Zhengping attempted crimes, sentenced to death, suspended for two years.
He Zhengping caught a picture from the network
On a little hole and He Zhengping have injured minibus car monitor screenshot
The Court heard
With cuts to staff 10 years old son
June 13, 2016 at 6 o’clock in the morning, heshan district of yiyang city of Hunan province Yue Jia Qiao children of hospital staff were stabbed by patient. Since then, the Hunan Public Security Bureau informed the official micro-blog, suspects He Zhengping hospitals and cooperative medical claims and other issues conflict with doctors in township hospitals, disrupting hospital with the hospital to negotiate with the normal work order, after being stopped by hospital staff pore, He Zhengping grudges, will bore a son stabbed knives.
Day of June, L3, He Zhengping under criminal detention on suspicion of manslaughter, 23rd was arrested.
Murder death sentence
Defendant appeals the penalty
Judgement shows He Zhengping, now 55, is Yue Jia Qiao Zhen Hongqi village, yiyang city, Hunan province, people, school, Barber.
Yiyang city of Hunan province intermediate people’s Court of first instance finds that He Zhengping’s behavior constituted the crime of intentional homicide.
On January 24, 2017, yiyang City Intermediate Court made a verdict, He Zhengping murder sentenced to death, suspended for two years and deprived of political rights for life; compensation in incidental civil action plaintiff hole economic losses of 87,000.
After the verdict, He Zhengping of the criminal part of the verdict, of appeal. He said Yue Jia Qiao town hospital is at fault, he didn’t kill intentionally, a penalty. He Zhengping application holes of the victims to identify the injury again, and asked to identify his own spirit conditions. He Zhengping advocates said a penalty.
The second instance
Crime wrote the suicide note said it would be “stronger”
Advance to the store to buy a knife
Second trial court found, in mid-May 2016, He Zhengping Hospital Yue Jia Qiao town, heshan district of yiyang city hospital inpatient treatment. In the meantime, He Zhengping require referral to hospital in yiyang city centre hospital. Hospital doctors, his condition having to yiyang Central Hospital for treatment. He Zhengping then go through the discharge formalities. Discharged from hospital a few days later, He Zhengping yiyang Central Hospital on their own. Is a cross-zone hospital, no referral to prove and is not declared in advance, He Zhengping of the yiyang central hospital treatment expenses fell by 10%.
He Zhengping believes that reimbursement rate decrease is Yue Jia Qiao Zhen Wei Sheng yuan did not give him a transfer proof, and you’ll find Yue Jia Qiao Zhen hospital, sought compensation from the hospital he reimbursed costs 300 yuan, was rejected by the hospitals. Wishes did not reach, He Zhengping to move hospitals office computers, hospital staff pore stepped in to stop it.
He Zhengping said the hole’s behavior led to his illness and Yue Jia Qiao Zhen hospital hospital for several days. Since then, losses he sought compensation from the hospital he was in hospital in the city, demanded an apology from hole to him, also called hospitals bear the costs of his hospitalization, his request was again rejected. During this period, wrote a suicide note He Zhengping.
On June 12, 2016, the Presidents in township hospitals and others He Zhengping Xu fruitless consultations on the matter again, He Zhengping is determined to kill people to vent their anger. At noon, He Zhengping Yue Jia Qiao town within a shop opposite the Credit Union purchased a single-edged knife, Yue Jia Qiao Zhen lived in a hotel near the hospital that night and wrote a suicide note in the hostel.
It is understood that He Zhengping said in a suicide note, he believes in yiyang central hospital reimbursement 10% less medical expenses, is the responsibility of Yue Jia Qiao town hospitals. He said to do “strength”, “donate my savings to the heshan district of yiyang city and Ziyang district of persons with disabilities, also can hole a little bit, make the holes a ‘ happy life ‘. ”
Premeditated and accounting to the President commit
See accounting son decided to start
5:30 A.M. Xu, Yue Jia Qiao Zhen He Zhengping knives to squat near the hospital, waiting to kill Xu or holes.
That day at 6 o’clock, He Zhengping hole of see a 10 year old son walked out of the hospital, decided to move in on hole, trailing children sit on the minibus to Luan Fengshan Pvt. Small holes on the bus sat on the bus window position on the second row, He Zhengping in the small hole on the front seat. CMB to launch soon, He Zhengping cutting knife up across to the small hole beside holes in head and neck with a knife, and stabbed continued to stab in the chest. Hole arm to protect his head shouting, Cai Mou drivers immediately stopped, rushed to the tail of the car claimed He Zhengping under the stainless steel knife, and He Zhengping control.
Mass hole sent to hospital for treatment, police rushed to the scene He Zhengping arrested.
Through identification, small hole right arm injuries constitute injuries two, with multiple soft tissue rupture constitutes a minor level, constitutes a minor secondary hemorrhagic shock. Hole body were 13 stab wounds, wounds accumulated 52.5cm.
The testimony of
More than 50 years old man stabbed boy
Bus driver Cai Mou said in testimony, boy sitting on the bus on the day window position on the second row, followed by a more than 50-year old man on the bus. Car out to 200 meters, he suddenly heard screams from mirrors to see men just get on to the little boy who just get on with a knife stab, he immediately stopped and rushed to the rear, take man knife grabbed, then drag the man off.
Photo yiyang, from today
Worried about his excesses have stepped forward to discourage
Injured the child’s father, Kong said, the child was stabbed because of his and He Zhengping of “friction”.
On May 30, 2016, the hole thanks to some quarrel He Zhengping and a physician, came to understand the situation. He Zhengping asked units to give him l0%, said no money had moved a computer, say to move the computer’s monitor. He holds He Zhengping, prevent him from making extreme behavior, when there was a nurse already several months pregnant, he and Vice President Xie Mou will sit on the Chair He Zhengping holding together. Later He Zhengping left the hospital, he had no contact with He Zhengping, but knowing He Zhengping to medical reimbursement to hospitals in trouble a few times.
Vice President of the hospital:
Spanned by patients in hospital reporting
Yue Jia Qiao town, heshan district of yiyang City Health Center in charge of the medical business Xie an, Deputy Director of the testimony showed that He Zhengping of complications from emphysema in Yue Jia Qiao town hospitals hospital two days later asked the hospital sent a car to send him to the yiyang Central Hospital for treatment. Doctors say his condition is not serious, third, yiyang city, suggested that he go to the hospital treatment, He Zhengping does not agree to go through the discharge formalities.
Xie Mou said, according to heshan district health-care provision, with reimbursement of hospital costs, outside the hospital by the patient’s own health insurance management to issue declaration forms, hospital does not have any responsibility about He Zhengping.
The Court found that
According to the illness does not agree to transfer
High Court in Hunan province, after that He Zhengping hospital is at fault, said Yue Jia Qiao town, after investigation, patients need a referral referral, doctor’s professional judgment is more accurate, which can better achieve the purposes of grading diagnosis and treatment, Yue Jia Qiao town hospitals consider the specific illness He Zhengping, disagrees with He Zhengping referral to yiyang Central Hospital, and without undue.
Yue Jia Qiao Zhen He Zhengping hospital normal discharge procedure a few days later, in the case of undeclared, go to yiyang Central Hospital, he Jia Qiao Zhen hospital, is not informed, He Zhengping in township hospitals in decline in the ratio of hospitalization expenses of yiyang Central Hospital was not at fault.
Planned revenge camp waiting for crime
Killing intentionally obvious
He Zhengping appeal without killing intent, after investigation, wrote a suicide note before He Zhengping crime planned revenge, buying tools of the crime as murder, waiting waiting waiting to commit crime, knife-stab stab victim in a row after small hole in head and neck, chest and more than more than 10 knife, in people continues to still hold when they intercepted the small hole poked thorns, kill people intentionally obvious. He Zhengping after arrest, subjective mens rea for his killing had several clear statements. Therefore, this ground of appeal cannot be established, the Court not to accept it.
Again He Zhengping application identification, but not fully justified, the Court not to accept it. He Zhengping applied for evaluation of his mental condition. The investigation, He Zhengping premeditated crime for spite, the real motive, after committing the crime during the first squat, tracking, and then continuously stabbed with a knife stabbed the victim to prove that they are sane, clear minds, have the normal ability to identify and control. So the application will not be agreed to.
On dispute of medical personnel son assault
Subjective evil, serious social harm
Courts believe that He Zhengping whims of medical expenses, are determined to kill after hospital staff, squat down with a knife after failed, hospital staff regardless of the dispute’s youngest son commit murder, aggravated crimes and crimes with cruel means, subjective evil, social harm is serious, should be sentenced according to law.
Hunan province High Court appeal dismissed by the Court of final appeal
Maintaining a suspended death sentence upheld
The Court found that He Zhengping had set out to deliberately kill, due to reasons independent of his will to succeed can be accomplished crime punishment, mutatis mutandis. Given He Zhengping attempted crimes, for its imposition of the death penalty, announced at the same time suspended it for two years.
On February 16, 2017, Hunan province Court of Final Appeal ruled that the High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the.